Retirement planning is a journey that requires careful navigation, especially when it comes to deciding how to withdraw your savings for spending. Choosing the right retirement strategy from the multitude of options available can be overwhelming. Today,I'll discuss three different withdrawal strategies: the Inflation-adjusted plan, the Spending Smile concept, and Guardrails Spending approach; each of these has unique benefits and considerations.

The Inflation Adjusted Plan: The Simple Approach

The Inflation-adjusted strategy is arguably the most straightforward approach to managing your retirement funds. It begins with setting a fixed withdrawal rate, typically around 4%, which is adjusted annually for inflation. This method aims to provide a consistent income stream, maintaining your purchasing power over the years. However, its rigidity may not adequately account for the ebbs and flows of personal spending needs or market fluctuations. As I showcase in the video, while simplicity is its strong suit, this strategy leans so far towards safety, that it may not fully help you to spend your retirement income potential should you retire during a time when the market does exceptionally well.

The Spending Smile: the natural way people usually spend money during retirement

The Spending Smile concept introduces a more dynamic approach to retirement spending. It acknowledges that spending tends to be higher at the beginning and end of retirement, with a dip in the middle years. This pattern reflects the initial enthusiasm for travel and leisure, followed by a more settled lifestyle and, eventually, an increase in healthcare costs. The Spending Smile allows for greater flexibility in budgeting, encouraging retirees to adjust their spending according to different life stages. Through more detailed screen clippings in the video, I illustrate how adapting withdrawals to mirror the Spending Smile can lead to a more personalized and potentially more satisfying retirement experience.

Modern Guardrails:

Sophisticated but simple. Building on the foundations of the previous strategies, the Guardrails Spending approach offers a sophisticated framework for managing retirement withdrawals. This strategy involves setting upper and lower limits (or guardrails) on your portfolio balance, signaling when to adjust spending to avoid depleting your funds prematurely or missing out on potential lifestyle enhancements. Unlike traditional guardrails that may inadvertently restrict spending, the Modern Guardrails version I propose incorporates age and market conditions adjustments, providing a more nuanced and adaptable strategy. In the video, we take a closer look at how Modern Guardrails function, using screen recordings to show how they work in different market situations, including during rocky times like in 2007 and the 1970s. I suggest checking out the video, as it visually shows the benefits of stress testing your strategy during memorable historical events to see how comfortable you are with it.

Choosing Your Path

Each of these three strategies—Inflation Adjusted, Spending Smile, and Guardrails Spending—offers a distinct approach to retirement spending.

+ Inflation-adjusted- provides simplicity and predictability.

+ Spending Smile- provides flexibility based on life stages.

+ Guardrails Spending- a sophisticated, adaptable method that updates for personal and market changes.

I wrote a detailed paper about how Modern Guardrails can also help you know when it's okay to spend more during retirement. I contrast how this approach compares to the Inflation-adjusted approach, one that attempts to start with a spending rate that is low enough to likely not fail over a thirty-year period vs. Modern Guardrails, which adjusts to reflect the current risk conditions. Both strategies can allow for vastly different amounts of spending in retirement. You can grab a copy of the Modern Guardrails paper here.

Never miss an upload by subscribing to our YouTube channel by clicking the bell, so you get all of my notifications. 

Ready to secure your financial future and optimize your retirement? Contact Nick Davis, your trusted Certified Financial Planner, for expert guidance in Dallas, Ft. Worth, Frisco, and beyond. Whether you need retirement planning, wealth management, 401k rollover assistance, or IRA guidance, Nick Davis Financial Advisor is here to help. Take the first step towards a brighter financial future – schedule a consultation here!